- Mar 15, 2023
What are the Nobel Prizes that were not deserved?
The Nobel Prize is one of the most prestigious awards in the world. It is awarded to individuals who have made outstanding contributions in the fields of physics, chemistry, physiology or medicine, literature, and peace. However, a few Nobel Prizes have been awarded to individuals who have not deserved them.
Here are a few examples of Nobel Prizes that were not deserved:
- The 1949 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine was awarded to António Egas Moniz for the development of prefrontal lobotomy. Lobotomy is a controversial procedure involving severing the connections between the brain's frontal lobes. It was originally developed as a treatment for mental illness, but it was later found ineffective and harmful.
- The 1973 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine was awarded to Andrew Schally and Roger Guillemin for their work on hypothalamic hormones. Schally and Guillemin did important work in this area but were not the first to do so. The work of other scientists, such as Henry Dale, was more significant.
- The 1994 Nobel Prize in Literature was awarded to Toni Morrison. Morrison is a talented writer, but her work does not stand up to the work of other writers who were not awarded the Nobel Prize, such as Gabriel García Márquez and Salman Rushdie.
- The 2016 Nobel Peace Prize was awarded to the European Union. The European Union is an important institution but has not done enough to promote peace. It has been involved in wars in the Balkans and in the Middle East.
Why do Nobel Prizes get awarded to the wrong people?
There are a few reasons why Nobel Prizes sometimes get awarded to the wrong people.
- Human error. A group of people awards the Nobel Prize, and it is possible that they make mistakes. They may not be aware of all the relevant information or make a judgment call that turns out to be wrong.
- Political considerations. The Nobel Prize is not just awarded for scientific or academic achievement. It can also be awarded for political reasons. This can lead to the award being given to someone who does not deserve it.
- Celebrities. Sometimes, the Nobel Prize is awarded to someone famous, even if they have not made a significant contribution to their field. This can happen because the Nobel Prize Committee wants to make a splash and attract attention.
A few things can be done to prevent Nobel Prizes from being awarded to the wrong people.
- More research. The Nobel Prize Committee should do more research before awarding the prize. They should consult with experts in the field and make sure that they are aware of all the relevant information.
- Public input. The Nobel Prize Committee should allow the public to have input into the selection process. This would help ensure that the prize is awarded to someone truly deserving.
- Changes to the rules. The rules for awarding the Nobel Prize could be changed to make it more difficult for the wrong people to win. For example, the prize could be awarded to teams of scientists, rather than to individuals. This would make it more difficult for one person to dominate the process and ensure the prize is awarded to the most deserving person or team.